A Hillary hater critic sent me a Daily Show Youtube clip in which the show’s host absolutely “destroys” Hillary for “lying” based on what FBI Director James Comey said in his presser excoriating Hillary only saving her the ultimate excoriation were he to recommend her indictment, which he didn’t,stating the evidence did not suggest that she did anything she could be indicted under the applicable law.
I have both “destroying” and “lying” in quotes because the truth is, for anyone who knows or understands the facts and law in this case, what Trevor has brilliantly done is to smear Hillary based on his genuinely not understanding the facts and law in the case which both actually support the opposite conclusion as to lying, namely, Hillary did not lie as Trevor claims, parroting a lie that is being peddled by mostly the right wing media but also equally ignorant or lying MSM reporters and pundits.
Here’s a breakdown for you to make my point:
In the clip, Trevor uses Hillary’s own words she has been saying and contrasts that with Comey’s own words contradicting them and thus leading Trevor and others reaching the same conclusion, namely, if what Hillary is saying is contradictory to what Comey is saying she must therefore be lying.
Both Comey and Hillary are telling the truth.
Hillary says she did not send “any classified material to anyone on [her] email.” Comey says “110 emails in 52 email chains have been determined to contain classified material at the time they were sent.”
However, Hillary has also been saying she did not send or receive any emails that were “marked” classified, it is true as Comey says that there were classified emails sent or received at the relevant time, but it’s also true as Hillary says she did not receive or send classified emails because they were not so marked as Comey confirms!
Comey, however, took exception to this, namely, Hillary saying none of the emails were not marked as “classified” saying even though these emails were not so marked, a reasonable person and therefore Hillary should have known the content of the email was classified information.
Indeed, this is mainly the reason why Comey excoriated Hillary that what she did was “extremely careless” even though not to the level of gross negligence required for criminal prosecution.
At the same time, Comey also said something that was extremely damning and initially provided the evidence that Hillary lied when he said a “small portion” of these emails were found to bear markings, which obviously directly contradicts what Hillary and those of us who have followed this closely said to ourselves, “that’s bad; no way both can be true.”
However, thanks to the stupidity of Congressional Republicans hauling Comey to testify but really as a means to discredit this highly regarded and respected civil servant—thanks to that stupidity Comey provided new information that completely removes this as a contradiction and makes what Hillary said about it not a lie.
As it turns out, the “small portion” that Comey was talking about were 3 emails out of more than 30,000 Hillary received and sent that were marked classified.
However, Comey under questioning from a sharp Democrat admitted that the markings in those 3 emails were not in conformity with rules governing how classified communication should be marked and, more importantly, Comey admitted that a reasonable person could have reached the same conclusion as Hillary did that these emails were not classified!
In other words, Comey shreds to pieces the charge that Hillary lied about not receiving marked classified emails because paltry 3 found to be marked were incorrectly marked to make what she said true despite what Comey said to the contrary.
As icing to the cake, Comey also admitted in this moronically called hearing what would have otherwise received little notice, namely, the fact that the State Department said the day before that 2 of those 3 emails did not after contain classified information because the classified marking the bore—incorrect as it were, were in error to begin with!
Meaning, there’s only 1 email out of more than 30,000 that bears a classified marking but as noted above, that marking was incorrect therefore leaving intact and true what Hillary has been saying about not receiving or sending emails marked classified.
The clip next shows Hllary saying she “provided all [her] emails that could be possibly work related” to SOS after being asked to do so but Comey says in the clip “several thousand that were not among the group of 30,000 emails returned.”
From this, Trevor and others charge that Hillary is therefore lying about this; how could she say she turned in ALL her emails when Comey found “thousands more” that were not turned in?
The answer is simple and Comey actually provided it in his presser except those eager to depict Hillary as a liar have no time to hear what he said, don’t care or the lying narrative is good for business, which is exactly the case in this Trevor clip.
Truth is, Comey said himself he found no evidence that email withheld any emails and provided an explanation for the additional emails found could have simply the case of technical inability to capture all emails in the various systems Hillary used over the 4-year period.
In other words, Hillary did not lie about this because at the time she said it, she actually believed she had produced all emails that could be possibly official email.
Hillary is next shown to say, they “went through a thorough process to identify all work related emails” but Comey says “lawyers doing the sorting did not individually read the content of all of her emails.”
Again, both are true and Hillary is therefore not lying about this either because the process her lawyers utilized to make sure all work related were identified and produced was “thorough” but you can’t compare that with resources at FBI disposal which is obviously more thorough but doesn’t mean the process Hillary used wasn’t thorough as she says it was therefore no lie here.
Hillary says she “thought it would be easier to carry just one devise” but Comey says she “used numerous devices. Again, no lie here because Hillary is talking about why she initially set-up her private server and her using a single device was part of that rationale even though she obviously later used more than one device.
Hillary has been saying “there were no security breaches” but Comey says “it’s possible hostile actors had access to SOS personal email account.” Again, anyone who bothered to listen or read the transcript of what Comey said would know there’s a simple explanation for this that makes both what Hillary said and what Comey said to be true, which means she’s not lying on this either.
Recall the server Hillary was using is that of her husband, the former president of the United States and therefore you would have to expect this is not some jua kali system as everyone who hates Hillary would have you believe and she has repeatedly said what was, in fact, confirmed that the system had safeguards to ensure security and was NOT HACKED despite numerous attempts.
Indeed, Comey specifically said they found no evidence of hacking but added the superfluous her critics are trying to milk, namely, that “it’s possible” the system could have been breached and they just couldn’t find the evidence but that was an irresponsible statement because it puts Hillary in a position to prove a negative in order to reconcile what she said and what he said.
However, for purposes of whether Hillary “lied” about this, what Comey found and said is enough to reach the conclusion she did not.
Given this sound analysis, it should be clear to anyone watching this clip that it’s not Hillary who’s lying but those who are saying she’s lying are the ones lying question is why?
Only three possibilities: (1) They hate Hillary therefore to them facts don’t matter or (2) they’re just lazy to take time to learn and understand all the facts or (3) they’re simply parroting the right wing lies to up their own ratings, Trevor is guilty of one or two of these hint: he doesn’t hate Hillary.
Please note I have provided more info that’s in the clip because that’s what a good analyst does and now the reader knows nothing but the whole the truth.
As I have been saying, now get ready for our next president of this already great country Hillary Clinton because a majority of voters just won’t allow the bigoted clown to become our president, especially more so under this climate we urgently need a coming together not reversing to the ugly past where bigotry and discrimination reigned unabashedly.