Elections Must Be Held In 2012, Not In 2013 As The Constitutional Court Ruled

13 Jan

A 3-judge panel of the Constitutional Court has ruled that the first elections under the new constitution should be held in 2013, unless the coalition partners President Mwai Kibaki and Prime Minister Raila Odinga agree to dissolve the coalition in which case the court ruled the elections must be held within 60 of dissolving the coalition.

Instead of clarifying the issue of when should the next elections be held, the court has confused Kenyans even more.

Indeed, the court is acting as if it’s interpreting a contract provision in which it is purporting to balance the monetary interests of Members of Parliament and the need to clean house and start afresh.

In so balancing, the court has concluded it’s better to have the MPs complete their contractual employment and therefore get their full pay instead of telling us what the constitution says about the election date.

The court is wrong on this and the Supreme Court must step in and fix the issue with the clarity it deserves.

The constitution is clear as to when the next elections should be and so one is left to wonder whether that meant anything to the court in its ruling.

Even before examining the constitution, a few facts are worth noting and these are first, it makes no sense to extend the life of Parliament, and by definition, the presidency, beyond five years, which is the term under which both were elected.

Second, depending on circumstances and what country, any elected politician’s term of office can always be cut short in any number of ways, including voluntarily, or by recall, death or expulsion, in the case of elected legislative body members or by impeachment, no vote of confidence, resignation, death, in the case of presidents and prime ministers.

The court therefore predicating its decision on the notion that the MPs must serve their term in full is without sound reason other than pleasing the MPs and that is not a good enough a reason to ignore what the constitution says.

Third, the public is served better, the more frequent and shorter the term of their elected officials and five years is the maximum number of years elected officials serve globally.

Both the current 10th Parliament and the President were elected under the old constitution, which set five years as the maximum period of time either can serve in office.

The new Constitution also sets five years as the maximum number of years members of the house and senate can serve, ditto for the president.

The question the court was asked to answer is when elections are to be held.

Under the old constitution, the president had the enviable powers to prologue or dissolve parliament at will and thus one of the many reasons MPs toed the president’s line and always sang to the tune of his music.

The new Constitution stripped the president of that power but did not expressly provide any other mechanism to dissolve Parliament in connection with holding new elections.

Some analysts, including Prof. Ghai and others appear to point to this as one of the reasons there is “uncertainty” as to when the first elections should be held under the new Constitution but there is nothing uncertain about when the first elections should be held.

Although the new Constitution stripped the president’s power to dissolve Parliament, and therefore cause new general elections, the new Constitution clearly fixed the date for the general elections for Members of Parliament, to be “on the second Tuesday in August in every fifth year.”

This date is mandatory and automatic under Article 101 of the constitution.

There is no more need for the president to dissolve Parliament in order for elections to take place and neither is such a declaration necessary; the clock starts ticking on the date of elections and on the second Tuesday in August of the fifth year, it’s go back to the people and seek a new mandate for MPs and the president.

Members of the 10th Parliament were elected—and I always use the term sparingly, given some were obviously rigged in, on December 27, 2007. The members were sworn in on that cantankerous 15th day of January, 2008, which means, the next Parliamentary elections must be on August 14, 2012, under Article 101 of the constitution (second Tuesday in August of the 5th year), counting from the date of election, not the date of swearing in.

This is the only interpretation that makes sense and, even though one other might (holding the first elections under the new Constitution in December 2012), all others must be viewed with great suspicion as mischief must be lurking underneath.


Posted by on January 13, 2012 in Law, Politics


Tags: , , , , ,

2 responses to “Elections Must Be Held In 2012, Not In 2013 As The Constitutional Court Ruled

  1. Henry

    January 13, 2012 at 8:37 AM

    This is the kind of legal mind that qualifies to be Kenya’ CJ.or if not CJ then then the constitutional court on elections should have consulted. March 2013 is not anywhere in constitution which is supreme law and which the three judges should have observed. But giving Kenyans a rather political ruling returns Kenya in the useles dark KANU juu juu juu juu zaidi days

  2. Samuel N. Omwenga

    January 13, 2012 at 9:35 AM

    Thanks Henry for the complement; I completely agree with what you have said about the judge rendering a political opinion, which they clearly have so let’s hope the Supreme Court steps in and makes the right decision.

    There is so much faith and confidence I have for the Supreme Court, being a new court with fresh faces but can’t say about the rest of the judiciary which is pretty much the old judiciary, save for some who are on the reform path. We have a long way to go but there is hope.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: